By Suzanna Martinez ·

Bridging the Deductible: Why GAP Insurance Is a Smart Strategy for Small Businesses

Calculator and binder, calculating insurance costs

September 25, 2025

Small businesses often face a tough balancing act: controlling health insurance costs while ensuring employees are protected from high out-of-pocket expenses.

We recently helped an 11-employee company save over $11,000 annually—all while dramatically reducing employee deductibles—by pairing a High-Deductible Health Plan (HDHP) with a GAP insurance policy.

This strategy is a proven way to maximize savings for the employer while keeping employee costs predictable and manageable.

What Is GAP Insurance?

GAP insurance is a supplemental health policy designed to cover the “gap” between what an HDHP pays and what employees owe out-of-pocket. Typically, it reimburses:

Think of it as a financial airbag, softening the blow of large medical expenses before the HDHP kicks in. The best part? Coverage can be surprisingly affordable, often starting around $40/month for an individual.

Benefits of GAP Insurance Strategies

Considerations and Limitations

While GAP insurance is powerful, small businesses should be aware of potential challenges:

Why This Strategy Works

Using a PEO Master Aetna HDHP paired with GAP insurance provides a textbook example of a win-win benefits strategy:

For small businesses, this combination strikes the perfect balance between savings and employee satisfaction, while helping HR teams manage renewals during Q4 efficiently.

Next Steps

Want to explore how GAP strategies could work for your business? We provide free, side-by-side comparisons tailored to your company.

Email: suzanna@peofortheceo.com to get started today.

Stay Tuned: In the next article in our Q4 series, we’ll cover “HRA vs. HSA: Smarter Cost Containment Strategies for Employers.”